vinSUITE - Blog - 3 Advanced Strategies to Elevate Your Wine Club

Blog Categories

3 Advanced Strategies to Elevate Your Wine Club—Are You Staying Ahead?

02/10/2025

Your wine club is performing well—members love your wines, shipments arrive on time, and revenue is strong. But in today’s hyper-competitive market, good enough isn’t enough.

Even the best wine clubs risk stagnation if they don’t evolve. Consumer expectations are shifting, and wineries that anticipate trends—not just react to them—are the ones that thrive.

The good news? These three advanced strategies will help you stay ahead, improve retention, and deepen member engagement—without overcomplicating your operations.

1. Spot At-Risk Members Before They Cancel

Most wineries track cancellations after the fact, but by then, it’s too late. The real key to retention is predicting churn before members leave—so you can intervene early and keep them engaged.

Are You Doing This Yet?

Identifying shipment skips: A one-time skip might be a fluke, but repeated skips? That’s a red flag. Members who skip two shipments in a row are twice as likely to cancel.
Tracking engagement across channels: Are members opening emails but never purchasing add-ons? Attending events but skipping shipments? Understanding these patterns helps you adjust outreach.
Recognizing tenure-based drop-offs: Many clubs see churn spike around the 18-month mark—so what are you doing to re-engage members at that stage?

Make It Work Without More Software

Run a churn risk report in your wine club software: Identify members with skipped shipments or declining order frequency.
Create a simple churn “watchlist” in Excel: Track skipped shipments, event attendance, and purchase patterns.
Set a calendar reminder to review churn-related data quarterly—trends emerge over time, not in a single month.
Test a proactive retention campaign: Offer a personalized incentive (like an exclusive wine) to members who’ve skipped multiple shipments.

🔎 Data-backed insight: Increasing retention by just 5% can boost profits by 25-95%. Small, proactive steps can have a major impact.

2. Go Beyond Personalization—Build Real Connection

Personalized shipments and flexible options? Those are the bare minimum today. True loyalty comes from something deeper—making members feel like they’re part of something exclusive, connected, and irreplaceable.

Are You Doing This Yet?

Micro-exclusivity: Instead of generic VIP tiers, create limited-run offerings for small member segments—like long-time members or event attendees.
Shared ownership: Let members vote on new wine blends, event themes, or label designs. Research shows that when people help create something, they feel more invested in it.
Surprise and delight moments: Unexpected perks—like a handwritten note from the winemaker or an anniversary bonus bottle—can create emotional connection and increase retention.

🔎 Data-backed insight: 60% of consumers say “unexpected rewards” increase brand loyalty.

3. Rethink Your Metrics—Are You Tracking What Really Matters?

You likely track revenue, average order value (AOV), and retention. But are you analyzing the right trends to drive future growth? The most successful wine clubs dig deeper—rethinking what their data actually tells them.

Are You Doing This Yet?

Breaking down AOV by purchase type: Are members spending more on certain wines? Use that data to curate future shipments and marketing offers.
Segmenting retention by behavior: Do long-term members engage with events or are they passive? Knowing this can refine your outreach.
Measuring referrals over time: How many new members join from word of mouth? If referrals are slowing, your club may need fresh energy.

Running a wine club is challenging—but keeping it exciting and relevant is even harder. By thinking ahead with predictive retention, next-level engagement, and smarter metrics, you can stand out from the competition.

At vinSUITE, we’ve spent over 20 years helping wineries streamline their wine clubs and discover new ways to thrive.

Take the Wine Club Scorecard for a personalized assessment and actionable insights you can implement today.

Post By: vinSUITE